| Name | Dates | |
| Casimir Ilg | November 15, 1911 | List Cases |
| Julius Illis | June 5, 1908 | List Cases |
| Donato Imbriani | June 1, 1910 | List Cases |
| Filippo Importuna | March 5, 1908 | List Cases |
| Antonio Impuluzzo | January 04, 1916 | List Cases |
| Giuseppe Indovino | April 17, 1916 - April 6, 1916 | List Cases |
| Vincenzo Indravaia | January 8, 1908 | List Cases |
| Giuseppi Ingalala | February 10, 1909 | List Cases |
| Giacomo Ingarra | July 24, 1917 | List Cases |
| Harry Ingram | June 4, 1915 | List Cases |
| Jesse Ingram | August 11, 1920 | List Cases |
| Vincenzo Inzeni | July 29, 1918 | List Cases |
| Pasquale Ippolito | October 19, 1914 | List Cases |
| Andrew Iquinto | June 22, 1920 | List Cases |
| Samuel Iquinto | January 9, 1913 | List Cases |
| Antonio Irone | June 9, 1903 | List Cases |
| Samuel Isaacson | November 10, 1914 | List Cases |
| Julius Isaakson | February 25, 1915 | List Cases |
| Charles Isola | July 15, 1912 | List Cases |
| Adolphe Israelowitz | March 25, 1918 | List Cases |
| Arthur Israels | February 26, 1918 | List Cases |
| Morris Issenoff | November 22, 1921 | List Cases |
The Crime in New York 1850-1950
digitization project was supported in part by funds from: Metropolitan New York Library Council (METRO) through the New York State Regional Bibliographic Databases Program.